My dogs are not enthusiastic about these treats. Before I got my puppy, I bought this for the older dog and she said, “meh”. I ended up donating it. When I got the puppy, I decided on using the trainers, which is the small version of these. The puppy took a few, but he wasn’t willing to work for it. Disclaimer— the puppy does what the older dog does, so he might’ve taken her lead on them, but still. I donated the trainer treats too. There are still plenty of other yummy treats for them to get at Farm Hounds, so no worries there.